Create a Santa & Reindeer Cookie Set Using Stencils

Jump to Recipe

Create an adorable Christmas cookie set featuring Santa's sleigh and three reindeer! This beginner-friendly design uses cookie stencils to make decorating quick and easy—no projector or complicated piping skills required.

Create a Santa & Reindeer Cookie Set Using Stencils
This post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure policy.

Looking for a festive Christmas cookie design that's easy to decorate but still looks impressive? This Santa's sleigh and reindeer mini cookie set is just the thing!

This 4-piece set includes Santa's sleigh and three adorable reindeer, all designed to look like they're flying through the Christmas sky. It's a fun little arrangement that's perfect for holiday cookie gifts, Christmas cookie platters, or adding something special to your holiday treat boxes.

The best part? You don't ned a projector or advanced decorating skills to recreate this design! We're keeping things super simple by using coordinating cookie stencils to add all the details.

Akaso Mini Projector

Take your cookie decorating to the next level!

Trace cookie designs with ease with the Akaso mini projector.
Buy on Amazon

Santa's Sleigh and Reindeer Mini Cookie Cutter & Stencil Bundle

To make recreating this Christmas cookie set, we have a this Flying Sleigh & Reindeer Cookie Cutter & Stencil Bundle available in our shop!

The bundle includes two mini cookie cutters—one Santa's sleigh and one reindeer—along with a coordinating stencil that adds all the festive details to both designs.

Even though there are only two cookie cutter shapes, you can create this adorable 4-piece set by making one sleigh cookie and three reindeer cookies.

flying sleigh and reindeer cookie cutter set with matchingstencil

The Cookie Decorating Process

Decorating cookies always starts with a good royal icing recipe. This is my favorite royal icing recipe that I use to decorate sugar cookies.

Royal Icing Colors

For this Christmas set, I used the following color combinations:

How to Decorate the Santa's Sleigh and Reindeer Cookies

Step 1: Flood the Cookies with White Icing

Start by outlining and flooding all four cookies with white royal icing.

Use a scribe tool to smooth out the icing and pop any air bubbles for a nice, even surface. Let this icing completely dry before moving on.

covering a Christmas cookie with white royal icing

Step 2: Position the Stencil in the Stencil Genie

Before applying the stencil design, you'll want to secure the stencil in a Stencil Genie holder.

For this mini cookie set, I recommend rotating the stencil 45 degrees inside the Stencil Genie frame, so it sits diagonally instead of straight.

This little trick gives the mini cookies more room away from the edges of the holder, making it easier to position the stencil design over each cookie.

The Stencil Genie still keeps the stencil securely in place, so you can apply the design without worrying about the stencil shifting.

Cookie Stencil at a 45 Degree Angle for Reindeer Design
Cookie Stencil at 45 Degree Angle for Santa's Sleigh Design

Step 3: Apply the Stencil Designs

Once the white icing has dried, it's time to bring these Christmas cookies to life!

Position the coordinating stencil over each cookie and carefully apply your stencil icing.

Gently lift the stencil straight up to reveal the design underneath.

Repeat this process for Santa's sleigh and all three reindeer cookies.

The stencils make it easy to achieve clean, consistent details across the entire set without having to pipe everything by hand.

Helpful Tip: Make sure your stencil icing is thick enough to hold its shape. If it's too runny, it can seep underneath the stencil and blur the details.

Santa's Sleigh Cookie using stencils

Step 4: Add Optional Icing Embellishments

If you want to give your cookies a little extra dimension, this is where you can have some fun!

After the stencil designs have set, use royal icing to add a few finishing touches.

For the reindeer, you can pipe their harnesses with bells, the noses, and darken the reins.

Easy Reindeer cookies using cookie stencils

For Santa's sleigh, consider adding icing details to the sleigh runners to make them stand out.

These little additions can really elevate the finished look, but they're completely optional.

If you're short on time, the stenciled designs look great all on their own!

Christmas Sleigh and Reindeer Cookie Decorating Video Tutorial

The steps above are summarized in this time-lapsed video I put together below.

A Festive Christmas Cookie Set Without the Fuss

I love how this mini set comes together to create one cohesive Christmas scene. When arranged in a row, the three reindeer look like they're pulling Santa's sleigh through the sky!

It's a charming design that works especially well for holiday cookie gift boxes or as part of a larger Christmas cookie assortment.

And because the decorating process is so straightforward, it's a great option when you need to make multiple sets for gifting or holiday orders.

In the photo below, I used our 2.75" x 10" Cookie box with this green gingham cookie backer in the background.

box set of a flying Sleigh with Reindeer mini cookies

Ready to Make Your Own?

If you've been wanting to try cookie stenciling, this Christmas mini set is a great place to start!

With just a simple white icing base and a few coordinating stencils, you can create an adorable Santa's sleigh and reindeer cookie set without the need for a projector.

You can find the Flying Sleigh & Reindeer Cookie Cutter & Stencil Bundle in our shop.

Happy decorating, and I hope this little Christmas set brings some extra holiday cheer to your cookie creations!

Add Vibrant Colors with Americolor Food Coloring

Americolor food coloring

To make your decorated cookies pop, use Americolor Food Coloring for bold, consistent colors. It’s my go-to brand for achieving vibrant shades without altering the consistency of the royal icing.

Buy Now
Tags:
Mike Tamplin, the founder and cookie decorator behind Semi Sweet Designs.
About the Author

Mike Tamplin

Hi, I’m Mike, the cookie decorator behind Semi Sweet Designs! Since 2011, I’ve been sharing recipes, tips, and tutorials to help beginners gain confidence and give experts fresh inspiration. Along with my brother, Billy, we design and offer hundreds of cookie cutters, stencils, and apparel—all made with decorators in mind.

Whether you're just starting or a seasoned pro, we’re here to make cookie decorating easier and more fun!

Read more
Become a member!
Become a shop member to unlock exciting perks. Earn points for every dollar spent. Plus extra ways to earn!
Join For Free