How to Make a Stackable Cat Witch Cookie Set

Written by Mike Tamplin • Sep 19, 2021

Take your cookie decorating to the next level!

Trace cookie designs with ease with the Akaso mini projector.

I've been a fan of stackable cookie sets ever since the Christmas tree version last year. Designing a stackable option for the holidays that followed (here are links to the the Easter bunny and school backpack designs) has been a lot of fun. This Halloween was no exception.

Just added to the shop is this cat witch cookie set. It's an adorable black cat, wearing a witch's hat, while atop a jack-o-lantern pumpkin. It may look intimidating as an overall design, but I promise you it's not. If you take a look at each cookie piece individually, each one is very approachable and not too complicated. I'll guide you through the process if you don't know where to start first.

As for the tutorial, this post is a long one, so I'll get right to it. Here's the detailed guide for each of the four pieces for this stackable cat witch cookie set.

Salem Broom Co Stencil and Cutters

In the shop for the upcoming Halloween season is this stackable cat witch cookie cutter set. This set comes in 4 pieces, each a different part of the Halloween cat design.

When assembled together, the set will fit inside in this BRP long cookie box (12″ x 5″ x 1.5″).

stackable cat witch cookie cutter set | Semi Sweet Designs

Templates for the Salem Broom Co Cookies

To help with the decorating process, I made a PDF template available for this year's Halloween cookie designs as a guideline.

You can download these cookie templates HERE.

If you have a Kopykake or Pico projector, just print it out (or pull it up on your mobile device) and you are good to go. For those without a projector, follow the suggested steps below by tracing the design onto the cookie with an edible food marker.

The Decorating Process

For this cat witch cookie set, you will need the following suggested colors:

Black royal icing. (I used Americolor Super Black.)
Purple icing. (I used Rainbow Dust Purple.)
Orange icing. (I used Americolor Orange.)
Green icing. (I mixed Americolor Egg Yellow with Mint Green.)
Yellow icing. (I used Americolor Egg Yellow.)
White icing. (I used Americolor Bright White.)
Pink icing. (I used Wilton Rose.)

Step 1

For the hat cookie, begin by filling in the purple sections of the hat first. Let that icing set.

Then fill in the green hat band in the middle. Let this icing dry for abour an hour.

Step 2

Next, add the square buckle detail over the green band, as shown.

Then add the outline details of the hat. Lastly, add that small, center buckle detail.

Step 3

For the head cookie, begin by filling in the face area first. Let that icing set.

Then add the pink details like the lower ear and the nose.

Step 4

Next, add the eyes, one eye at a time. I used the wet-on-wet technique and etched where I wanted the eyes first.

Then I started with the outer white part, then the green, then the black pupil, and lastly the two white reflection dots. This had to be done quickly. Shake the cookie to smooth out the icing.

Also, add the top of the ear section.

Finish the face by adding the mouth lines and the eyelashes.

Step 5

For the body cookie, start by filling in the center body section with black icing. Let that icing set.

Then fill in the two hind leg areas and the purple collar.

Step 6

Complete the body by adding the tail, the moon charm, and piping on the feet outline details.

Step 7

For the bottom jack-o-lantern cookie, begin by applying a thin layer of black icing to the center of the cookie, as shown. I used an offset spatula to quickly spread an even layer across the middle where the face would be.

Step 8

For those without a projector, score or etch guidelines where the face details should be, as shown. I made a template with template plastic from the PDF file above and used a scribe tool to etch the guideline on the cookie.

Step 9

Next, with orange piping icing, outline around the eyes, mouth and around the entire cookie. Then flood with orange flood icing. Let this icing set for twenty minutes.

Lastly, outline around the edge of the cookie for added definition.