Father’s Day Cookies- Vintage Gas Pumps Tutorial

By now, you might know that I have a great appreciation for anything vintage or retro, as evident by my old-fashion telephone cookies, retro back-to-school cookies, vintage vacation cookies, and vintage letter cookies. (By the look at that list, maybe what I have is more of an obsession than an appreciation.) Can you blame me? There’s just something timeless about the classic look of how charming things were back in the day.

That being said, “timeless” and “classic” seemed like great themes for the upcoming Father’s Day holiday. I figured why not do (yet another) vintage set that I think most dads would appreciate– Father’s Day cookies with an old-fashioned automobile twist. Just to give you an idea, here’s a tutorial for making vintage gas pump cookies included in the set.

Preparing the Dough

The vintage gas pump cookies are made by using the boy cookie cutter from KarensCookies.net. Simply trim off the feet portion before baking and you have the basic gas pump shape.

Making father's day cookies

Decorating Process

  1. 1

    Sketch the Basic Shape

    To help with the icing process, sketch out the basic shape first with a food marker. Drawing perfect circles can be tricky, so use a small circle cutter as a guide for the top area.

    Vintage gas pump cookies- step 1
  2. 2

    Fill the background

    Next, fill the tiny neck area with gray 20-second royal icing. Also, with off-white 20-second icing, pipe and fill a rectangle in the middle of the main pump area. Give the icing time to dry and crust over.

    Once the gray and white icing had time to set, outline over your sketched lines with red (or your color of choice) piping icing, then fill with flood icing. Let the icing dry completely before moving on.

    vintage gas pump cookies - step 2
  3. 3

    Add Gray and Colored Details

    After the base icing had time to dry completely it’s time to add the details. First add the gray accents by outlining a border around the white rectangle, adding a side crank handle, piping a line across the top, and adding a gray box detail in the middle.

    Next, add the top, inner circle with off-white 20-second icing. Also, add the gas pump handle and bottom accents with colored icing.

    vintage gas pump cookies - step 3
  4. 4

    Add Black Details

    Lastly, add the black gas hose with black piping icing and a #2 tip. For the fine black details, I used my trusty Rainbow Dust food pen. Make sure to used the food pen only after the icing is completely dry and hardened.

    I’m horrible writing letters freehand. So for the word, “GAS”, I printed out the word in Britannica Bold font and used my Kopykake projector to guide me.

    vintage gas pump cookies -step 4

Below are a few finished gas pump cookies. As you can see, I had a little fun trying out different colors.

Vintage Gas Pump Cookies by Semi Sweet Designs

To accompany these gas pumps, I made a few old-timey, Model-T inspired automobiles. Just like my previous beach chair post, I also used the Sugarbelle bus cutter (which is quickly becoming my favorite go-to cutter) for these cars.

Vintage Car Cookies by Semi Sweet Designs

And finally, to really seal the deal of these Father’s Day cookies, I added a Father’s Day pun on a plaque cookie with the phrase…

Vintage Father's Day Cookies by Semi Sweet Designs

For more vintage, automobile-themed inspiration for cookies, check out these:

Vintage Car Father's Day cookies by Semi Sweet Designs

This post is linked up to these link parties.


Filed under:

27 replies on “Father’s Day Cookies- Vintage Gas Pumps Tutorial

  1. These are simply Amazing, Mike !!!!

    1. Thank you, Nancy. :)

  2. Fantastic theme and brilliantly done.you are clever!

    1. Thanks so much, Anjum!

  3. Gah, you amaze me Mike.

  4. Your cookies are classic and timeless Mike! I love how you can make amazing classic cookies out of simple cutters.

    1. Thanks, Lisa! I could say the same about you!

  5. Love them all! Great car design! and the colors, as usual…

  6. I have to say, I think YOU’RE a classic! Love each and every cookie~

  7. You are a rockstar as always Mike! I’ll be featuring your cookies on this weeks Party in Your PJs. Thanks for linking up :)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *